Q1. I am finishing my basement and planning
to incorporate a home theatre. We are working with a budget so keeping
costs to a reasonable level is important. Could you please give me some
advice regarding general room construction that will provide the best environment
for the theatre?
A1. There are many different
factors that go into designing a custom home theatre. Here are a few simple
rules that will ensure you get the best performance possible. You are
starting from scratch so first you need to decide on the dimensions of the
theatre. Ideally, no two room dimensions should be equal (ie. length 14' x
width 14'). Stay away from a square room. Rectangular shaped rooms are good
and a room that tapers out from from to back is ideal. For the best possible
bass reproduction the room should be completely enclosed and sealed with a
heavy door. If the room is not sealed properly the sound will escape into
the rest of the house, and you may need additional or more powerful
subwoofers in order to achieve ideal levels of bass
For the construction of the walls, use 2'x4's on 16"
centers. Add bridging between each 2'x4' stud to ensure the walls are as
rigid as possible. For the construction of the ceiling, stay away from
suspended ceilings as they tend to rattle. A drywall ceiling is ideal. Fill
all cavities in both the ceiling and walls with sound absorbing insulation.
Q2.
We have an extra room in our house that we would like to turn into a home
theatre. Could you give me some advice on the finishing of the room so that
the theatre will achieve its optimal performance?
A2. For the finishing of the theatre's walls and ceiling
use as dark a colour palette as you can. Charcoal gray is ideal. With new
projection technologies, such as DLP, there is a substantial amount of
ambient light reflected off of the screen. The darker colours will help
reduce the reflected light in the room to an acceptable level. If possible,
use a paint that has a flat finish. This will also help in the reduction of
reflected light.
A heavy carpet installed over good quality underlay will
help in the absorption of undesirable sound waves. Again, the darker the
colour the better. Stay away from hardwood floors as they reflect sound.
All glass doors and windows should be covered with
drapery constructed out of the heaviest material available. The drapery will
not only reduce undesirable reflected sound waves, but will also control
light levels in the theatre. We design all of our
systems with extreme care and attention to detail. We strive to offer a
level of customer satisfaction unsurpassed in the industry.
Q3. I am wiring a room in my house
that will be used as a home theatre. Any advice you could give me regarding
lighting control and configuration, as well as general electrical
requirements I may need, would be appreciated.
A3. I would recommend that you or your electrician
install at least one 15amp dedicated circuit for your stereo components.
Depending on the power requirements of your equipment, a second 15amp
circuit may be needed. The reason for dedicated circuits is to ensure that
all your components have ample power to operate at their highest level.
For lighting, use at least two different banks of
lights; one bank for general lighting of the room and the other bank or
banks to create a warm and cozy atmosphere through the use of ambient light.
Each bank should be controlled independently by its own dimmer. During movie
viewing, some ambient light is required to reduce the strain on your eyes.
By installing different banks of lights you will be able to control the
light level in the room so that it does not affect the performance of your
video display.
Wall sconces and pot lights installed around the outside
of the theatre work very well in achieving the desired lighting effect. If
you are using either a direct view or rear projection television, the
installation of a light that creates diffused light behind the television
will help reduce the strain on your eyes.
Q4. I am in the market for a video
projector for my home theatre. Could you please explain the differences
between a DLP, LCD, and CRT projector?
A4. CRT offers the best image but they also are the most
expensive. Prices range from $15,000- $75,000+. The image they produce is
very "film like". Their downfall is that they are fairly large, need to be
mounted in a fixed position, and need a dark environment to operate at their
best. They also need to be re-calibrated every few months by a technician.
For about $25,000 you can get a good projector that produces an excellent
image.
An LCD projector is used mostly for business
presentations. They are small in size, easy to setup, and are the least
expensive. Their downfall is that their image isn't that great. The image is
made up of tiny pixels and they are visible. They look like tiny dots. They
work well with text or simple graphics but when watching a movie the image
is less then great. A lot of people choose them for a Home Theatre
application because of their price. They range from $ 6,000- $15,000. Sony
has an LCD projector for about $11,000 that produces a very nice image and
will also display HDTV.
DLP is a new technology that was developed by Texas
Instruments. Like LCD, DLP projectors are very small, easy to setup, and
easy to operate. The image is more "film-like" than LCD. There are also
products out there that are able to improve the image. The price of a DLP,
transcanner (which improves the image), and a screen is approximately
$10,000. DLP technology is the way to go for a home theatre application,
unless you have the budget for a CRT.
|
Q5. We are in the process of
furnishing our family room. We plan on using the room as a home theatre.
Before we purchase the furnishings, are there any tips you could give us
that will help the theatre perform at its best?
A5. Ideally, the couches and chairs for the room
should be constructed out of as dense a material as possible (ie. the
heavier the fabric and the more stuffing or foam, the better). The extra
material used in the construction of the furniture will assist in the
absorption of undesired, reflected sound waves. The colour of the
furnishings should be as dark as possible to keep reflected light levels as
low as possible. Avoid glass objects such as tables, bookshelf doors and
walls, as the sound will reflect off of these objects thus affecting the
sound. Bookshelves filled with books will help reduce the undesirable
reflected sound waves.
Q6. I am doing research on which
speakers will work the best in my new home theatre.What are the basic
factors I should be looking into.
A6. There are so many different factors that go
into speaker selection that I could write an entire book on the subject.
Here are some basic rules that will keep you on the right track in the
selection of your speakers. The single most important factor is that all
speakers have similar or preferably identical sound characteristics. To
achieve the same sound from all the speakers its is preferable that you
purchase all of your speakers from the same manufacturer.
Most speaker manufacturers offer different speakers
(ie. front, centre, surround... ) that incorporate the same drivers
(tweeters, woofers, etc.). The reason for the speakers having the same
characteristics is simple. During the movie, as the sound travels around the
room, any difference in sound characteristics will be noticeable. This can
become distracting and will take away from your movie viewing experience.
The left and right main speakers will handle most major sound effects during
movie playback, as well as normal two channel stereo listening. For this
reason, I recommend spending more money on these speakers. However, do not
sacrifice the quality of your centre channel speaker, as this speaker, in my
opinion, is the most important in a home theatre speaker system. All
dialogue, as well as sound effects, are reproduced through the centre
channel speaker. The human voice is one of the hardest sounds to reproduce
accurately. A quality centre speaker is required for the most accurate
reproduction.
The surround speakers handle the sound effects that
create the ambiance in the room. They can be smaller in size than the main
speakers, but again, similar sound characteristics are important. The
subwoofer will handle all of the low sounds from movie soundtracks and
music. A quality sub or two greatly increases the enjoyment and realism
while watching a movie or listening to music. The better the sub, the more
realistic sound effects, such as explosions, will sound.
Q7. Which type of surround sound
speaker should I purchase?
A7. There are different technologies used in the
construction of surround sound speakers; dipole, bipole, and direct
radiating. Dipolar and bipolar speakers are designed to produce sound to the
front and rear of the room equally. The ideal listening position is in the
null area - the point where they don't directly project sound.
The idea of bi-polar and di-polar speaker design is
to achieve the greatest ambiance possible. The difference between Dipolar
and bipolar is the drivers in bipolar speakers are in phase (the front
driver and rear driver move forward and back at the same time) and Dipolar
drivers are out of phase (when the front firing driver moves forward, the
rear firing driver moves back). Dipolar speakers are said to create a more
diffuse sound field. When using direct radiating speakers for surround
sound, the sound is more easily located (ie. a sound coming from the right
rear of the sound stage will sound like it is coming from the right rear of
the room instead of the sound surrounding you from the entire right rear
area of the room).
Most experts select dipole speakers for the
surround channel. However, if you plan on using your theatre to listen to
new multi-channel audio formats, such as SACD and DVD-audio, then I
recommend direct radiating.
Q8. I have a DVD-ROM drive in my
computer. I have purchased a sound card with a digital output and a video
card with S-video output. Will this setup perform as well as stand alone DVD
player designed for home use?
A8. The audio performance of the DVD-ROM drive in
your computer will be noticeably worse than a stand alone unit. As of now,
with a high quality sound card the engineers have yet been able to reproduce
dolby digital at an acceptable level. Yes it will work, but not well. The
funny thing is if all of the information from the DVD-ROM was on your hard
drive, the quality of the audio would approach a more acceptable level. The
video performance of a DVD-ROM drive is also subpar. From what industry
experts are saying, computers and their components will be able to reproduce
excellent quality images sooner rather than later.
|
Q9. I am having problems with the
positioning of all the speakers in my home theatre. Can you help me locate
them properly?
A9. Speaker placement depends on many different
variables such as room dimensions, furniture layout, type of speaker, etc.
Here are some general rules that will give you an idea where each speaker
should be positioned. In order for the best possible performance of your
home theatre speaker system some tweaking may be required.
The left and right main channels should be placed
at an equal distance from the centre of your screen. To determine the
distance between the left and right speaker, a general rule of thumb is your
main listening position should be 1.5 times the distance between the two
speakers. Eg. Main listening position is 12' away, then speakers should be
8' apart. The speakers should be placed slightly ahead of your viewing
screen so that a gentle arch is created. This will ensure that the sound
will not reflect off of your television screen. The speaker's tweeters
should be at your ear level when you are seated. The speakers should be
slightly turned inward so that when you are listening to two channel stereo
the sound sounds like it is coming from the middle of the two speakers.
The centre channel should be placed either directly
above or below your screen. If you are using a projector/screen
configuration, you can purchase a perforated projection screen that you can
place the centre channel directly behind. If you have a big screen TV and
you are placing the speaker on top of it, then you may want to either angle
the centre channel speaker down or raise the left and right main speakers
slightly. The idea is to create a front sound stage that reproduces sounds
uniformly as they travel across the room. A sound effect such as a jet
flying across the screen should not sound like it dips or rises.
The surround channel is a whole different ballgame.
There are different types of surround speakers; dipole, bipole, and direct
radiating (For more information on the different types, see question 6).
Dipolar and bipolar speakers should be placed on the side walls at least
1.5' above ear level, parallel with the main seating area. Direct radiating
speakers should be placed behind the main seating area, to the far left and
right of the room. They should be positioned well above ear level and you
may want to adjust their positioning so that they angle up or down or left
or right. Trial and error works the best for positioning direct radiating
surround speakers. There are many other options for surround speaker
placement such as in-ceiling, in-wall, etc. It all depends on your desired
performance and aesthetics.
The subwoofer placement in your room has the most
possible positioning options. Room dimensions, furniture type and placement,
subwoofer quality and performance are just a few factors that can affect a
sub's performance. Placing the sub in a corner will help increase the bass
levels in the room. Once all of the furnishings are in the room, you can
start by placing the sub in either the front left or right corner. Using
either a CD or DVD you are familiar with, that reproduces lots of bass, have
someone move the sub in and out, back and forward, while you are seated in
the various positions in the room. Ideally, you shouldn't be able to tell
where the subwoofer is positioned. The bass should be tight, not boomy. The
bass should not linger and it should sound the same from the different
seating positions. You may have to move the sub around the room or purchase
a second subwoofer in order to create uniform bass response.
Q10. I am in the market for a new
television and I am confused about terms such as "HDTV compatible", "HDTV
ready", and displays HDTV. Could you please explain the difference in these
terms? Do you recommend purchasing a TV that displays HDTV?
A10. Almost every customer I have spoken with is
just as confused on this topic as you are. HDTV is a new video display
technology that is being gradually introduced in North America. The
performance of HDTV far surpasses our current NTSC standard. Here in Canada,
we are several years behind the Americans due to the fact that the CRTC is
run by a bunch of incompetent individuals. In every major and some minor
American television markets, consumers are able to view HDTV through either
an antenna on the roof or through cable. Canadians are able to view some
HDTV programming through mini-dishes such as Star Choice. When the majority
of the population in Canada will have access to HDTV programming is still up
in the air. In order to view HDTV, you will need not only a video display
that can reproduce HDTV but you will also need a separate HDTV decoder. Some
HDTV televisions, cable boxes, satellite receivers, etc., have the decoders
built in.
In response to your question, "HDTV ready" and
"HDTV compatible" is one of the most misleading phrases I have ever come
across in consumer products. What manufacturers mean by saying "HDTV ready"
or "HDTV compatible" is that once HDTV becomes available the consumer can
purchase an HDTV decoder. The decoder will convert the HDTV signal to our
current NTSC signal and the image can be displayed on that television. The
television will work but you will not be watching HDTV. In order to be able
to watch HDTV you need a television that will display the various HDTV
formats.
As for whether you should purchase a television
that displays true HDTV now, if you can afford the extra cost of an HDTV
display, then I recommend buying one. Video displays designed for viewing
HDTV material also do an excellent job of displaying what we are watching
now, NTSC. Keep in mind that when HDTV does finally become mainstream, the
screen ratio will be different from what we are viewing today. HDTV's format
is 16:9 (which resembles the shape of a screen in a commercial movie
theatre) and NTSC, what we are watching today, is 4:3. Many manufacturers
are making HDTV displays in the 4:3 format so that the current NTSC image
will fill the whole screen. If you do decide to purchase a HDTV widescreen
(16:9) display there will be black bars on the left and right side of the
screen if you are watching television. A letterboxed DVD or VHS movie will
fill the entire 16:9 screen. Keep in mind most DVDs only come in the
widescreen (16:9) format. In the future when HDTV is available, HDTV
displayed on a television in the 4:3 format will have black bars on the top
and bottom of the screen.
In my opinion, if you can afford an HDTV display,
purchase a 16:9 TV if you watch mostly DVDs. If you watch mainly television
and VHS movies, then purchase a 4:3 TV.
|